On a $20 plate, a home cook nets about $18.52 on Makinson Street (3% commission plus Stripe's 2.9% + 30¢; in-person payments are fee-free), roughly $17 on Shef (which has publicly cited a 15% cut, with some 2026 reports putting the effective take higher), and $14–$17 on DoorDash or Uber Eats (15–30% commission by plan). The bigger difference is legal: California MEHKO permits prohibit third-party delivery, so DoorDash and Uber Eats aren't an option for a permitted home cook at all.
Makinson Street vs. Shef vs. DoorDash: What Each Platform Takes From a Home Cook (2026)
Side-by-side fees for home cooks on Makinson Street, Shef, DoorDash, and Uber Eats — commission, payment processing, who's legally allowed to use which, and what a $20 plate actually nets on each.
The comparison
| {{app}} | Shef | DoorDash / Uber Eats | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Commission on card orders | 3% | 15% publicly cited; some reports put the effective rate higher | 15% (Basic) / 25% (Plus) / 30% (Premier) |
| Payment processing | Stripe: 2.9% + 30¢, passed through | Included in commission | Included in commission |
| In-person / cash payments | Fee-free | Not supported | Not supported |
| Listing or subscription fee | None | None | None (but paid ads and promotions) |
| Who delivers | Maker, or customer pickup | Shef arranges delivery | Platform couriers |
| Legal for MEHKO makers? | Yes — ordering marketplace, no third-party delivery | Depends on delivery arrangement and county | No — third-party delivery is prohibited (HSC §114367.5) |
| Permit verified before listing | Yes, every maker, displayed on profile | Food safety certification required; varies by state | Requires a commercial food facility permit |
| Maker sets own price | Yes | Yes, within guidelines | Yes, but platform markups common |
| Maker sets own schedule / menu days | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Payout | Stripe, automatic | Weekly | Weekly (daily for a fee) |
| Customer relationship | Direct — messages, reviews, regulars | Through platform | Through platform; customer data withheld |
What a $20 plate nets, and what 90 plates a week nets
| Per $20 plate | 90 plates/week, per year (4,680 plates) | |
|---|---|---|
| Makinson Street, card | $18.52 | $86,670 |
| Makinson Street, in-person | $20.00 | $93,600 |
| Shef at 15% | $17.00 | $79,560 |
| Shef at 30% (reported effective) | $14.00 | $65,520 |
| DoorDash / Uber Eats, 15% plan | $17.00 | $79,560 |
| DoorDash / Uber Eats, 30% plan | $14.00 | $65,520 |
Over a year at full MEHKO volume, the gap between Makinson Street and a 30% platform is more than $21,000 — before counting the ingredients you'd have bought either way.
Why the legal column matters more than the fee column
California's MEHKO law, AB 626, defines a home kitchen operation as one where food is eaten on site, picked up by the customer, or delivered by the operator or their employee (Health & Safety Code §113825). The follow-up bill AB 377 (2019) made the delivery rule explicit in §114367.5: food from a MEHKO "shall not be delivered by a third-party delivery service," the person delivering must be an employee, family member, or household member of the permitholder, and the single exception is for customers whose disability prevents them from picking up. §114367.6 binds the platform too — an intermediary "shall not use, or knowingly facilitate the use of, a third-party delivery service." That's why you don't see MEHKO makers on DoorDash — being there would put their permit at risk. The law does allow internet food service intermediaries: marketplaces that handle listing, ordering, and payment but not delivery. Those platforms must register with CDPH, display the maker's permit number, and disclose that food is made in a home kitchen. That's the category Makinson Street is built for; here's how we verify each maker.
Where Shef fits
Shef is the largest venture-backed home-cook marketplace in the U.S. and operates a delivery model in many markets, which is a different legal footing than a MEHKO in California — it has historically relied on makers working under cottage food or commercial-kitchen arrangements depending on the state. It's a real option, with real demand. The trade-offs are the commission, a platform-mediated customer relationship, and menu and pricing guidelines. If you want the widest reach and don't mind the cut, it's worth a look; if you want to keep your regulars and your margin, that's what we're for.
What Makinson Street doesn't do
- We don't deliver. Makers arrange pickup or do their own delivery. That's the law for MEHKOs, and it keeps the price down.
- We don't run ads against you. There are no paid placements or promoted listings.
- We don't take a cut of cash. If a regular hands you $20 at the door, that's yours.
Tell us where you cook. Many makers are listed the same day.
Completely free for orders paid in person (3% plus Stripe's processing fee on card payments). No listing fees, no subscription.
- Every order, pickup and message in one place.
- A verified profile customers trust.
- Found by neighbors and local search.
- Cook for your street or your whole city.
Frequently asked questions
What percentage does Shef take from makers?
Shef has publicly cited a 15% commission on maker revenue to cover marketing, payment processing, and support. Some 2026 reporting puts the effective take closer to 30% once other fees are included. Confirm current terms directly with Shef before signing up.
Can a MEHKO maker sell on DoorDash?
No. California's MEHKO law prohibits third-party delivery services from delivering home kitchen food (the one exception is for customers whose disability prevents pickup). Delivery must be by the operator or their employee, or the customer picks up. Ordering marketplaces that don't deliver are allowed.
What does DoorDash charge restaurants?
DoorDash's published partnership plans charge 15% (Basic), 25% (Plus), or 30% (Premier) commission on delivery orders, plus 6% on pickup orders. Uber Eats has a similar 15/25/30% structure.
What does Makinson Street charge makers?
3% of the plate price on card orders, plus Stripe's standard processing fee (2.9% + 30¢). In-person payments are fee-free. No listing fees, no subscription, no ads.
- DoorDash — Partnership plans and pricing
- Uber Eats — Merchant pricing
- Shef commission reporting (SideHusl)
- Stripe — Pricing
- California Health & Safety Code §113825 — MEHKO definition and delivery rules
- California Health & Safety Code §114367.5 — MEHKO delivery rules
- AB 377 (2019) — bill text
- California Health & Safety Code §114367.6 — internet food service intermediaries
Regulations and fees change. This guide was last reviewed on Sep 13, 2026; confirm current requirements with the issuing agency. Nothing here is legal or tax advice.